Pepe's Cafe Menu
78 items in 12 sections · $4.45 – $39.95 · American Restaurant in Key West, FL
Pepe's Cafe’s menu lists 78 dishes and drinks, grouped into Appetizers, House-Made Soups, Salads, Sandwiches, America, and Draft Beer and more. Prices range from $4.45 to $39.95, and a typical item costs about $16.45. Popular choices include Black Bean Soup, Pepe's Mustard Bbq Pulled Pork Sandwich, Gulf Cysters, Mixed Green Salad, and Key West Local Beer & Ipa's.
Appetizers 3
- Gulf Cysters
- Baked Oysters
- Rudi Style
House-Made Soups 3
- Black Bean Soup$9.95
- Chili$7.95
- Soup Of The Day$8.95
Salads 1
- Mixed Green Salad
Sandwiches 13
- Pepe's Mustard Bbq Pulled Pork Sandwich$15.95
- Grilled Cheese Sandwich$9.95
- Blt$14.95
- Club Sandwich$16.45
- Thanksgiving Sandwich Roasted$15.45
- Chicken Breast Sandwich$16.45
- Fresh Local Fish Sandwich
- Pepe's Steak Sandwich$18.95
- Pepe's Burger$15.95
- Slit Ray Burger$18.95
- Patty Melt$16.95
- Grilled Portobello Mushroom Sandwich$14.95
- New York Strip Steak$24.95
America 1
- Key West Local Beer & Ipa's
Draft Beer 2
- Pepe's Ale
- Yuengling Lager
Off Island 6
- Corona
- Corona Light
- Heineken
- Red Stripe
- Stella Artois
- Dos Equis
Side Orders 5
- Link Sausage
- Smoked Sausage
- Home Fries$4.45
- Grits
- Potato Patty$4.95
Omelets 4
- Cream Cheese And Scallions$13.95
- Mild Green Chili And Monterey Jack Cheese$13.95
- Western$16.45
- Pepe's Steak$18.95
Pepe's Famous Drinks 14
- Margarita
- Passion Fruit Jalapeno Margarita
- Peperita
- Strawberry Mango Screwdriver
- Bloody Mary
- Mimosa
- Screwdriver
- Greyhound
- Pepe's Pilar Rum Punch
- Orange Crush
- Grapefruit Crush
- Bombora Mule
- Cool Cucumber
- Mojitos
Late Entrees 9
- Choice New York Strip$31.95
- Pepe's Chicken Breast Florentine$23.95
- Key West Pink Shrimp
- Half Chicken$22.95
- Two Center Cut Pork Chops$27.95
- Fresh Vegetarian Plate$14.95
- Pepe's Steak Smothered In Pork Chops$39.95
- Burger 8oz$18.95
- Fresh Local Fish Sandwich$21.95
Others 17
- Key West Pink Peel N' Eat Shrimp$16.95
- Local Smoked Fish Dip$16.95
- Stone Crab Claws
- Margarita
- Passion Fruit Jalapeno Margarita
- Peperita
- Strawberry Mango Screwdriver
- Bloody Mary
- Mimosa
- Screwdriver
- Greyhound
- Pepe's Pilar Rum Punch
- Orange Crush
- Grapefruit Crush
- Bombora Mule
- Cool Cucumber
- Mojitos
How these prices compare
Based on 177 menus with 11,760 priced items from American restaurants in Florida, the median menu item costs $11.75, and half of all items are priced between $6.00 and $17.00.
At Pepe's Cafe the median listed price is $16.45, higher than the typical $11.75 for American restaurants in Florida.
| Item | Here | Typical |
|---|---|---|
| Blt | $14.95 | $12.50 |
| Patty Melt | $16.95 | $13.00 |
Typical prices are calculated from 177 menus in our guide.
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated May 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.